 | Emeka Okafor 2003-2004 Virginia Gentlemen |  | Andrew Bogut 2004-2005 Prozac Pups |  | Paul Millsap 2005-2006 Tuleburg Paper Tigers |
 | Kevin Durant 2006-2007 Saluki YRD’s |  | Lester Hudson 2007-2008 Deep Valley Grouchos |  | Blake Griffin 2008-2009 Maize and Blue Bloods |
 | Artsiom Parakhouski 2009-2010 Sam Jacobson Went to Class |  | Kenneth Faried 2010-2011 Saluki YRD’s |  | Kevin Jones 2011-2012 Pyschos |
 | Mike Muscala 2012-2013 Tuleburg Paper Tigers |  | Jerrelle Benimon 2013-2014 Deep Valley Grouchos |  | Jameel Warney 2014-2015 Deep Valley Grouchos |
 | Pascal Siakam 2015-2016 Deep Valley Grouchos |  | Jacob Wiley 2016-2017 Deep Valley Grouchos |  | Marvin Bagley 2017-2018 Maize and Blue Bloods |
 | Dylan Windler 2018-2019 Deep Valley Grouchos |  | Terry Taylor 2019-2020 Gator Bait | | Terry Taylor 2020-2021 Gator Bait |
 | Oscar Tshiebwe 2021-2022 Vindaloos |  | Zach Edey 2022-2023 KC Warthogs | | Zach Edey 2023-2024 KC Warthogs |
 | Oscar Cluff 2024-2025 Deep Valley Grouchos |